CS Karnan passed away on 12th
November at Chennai. He was one of the most controversial Judges of the High
Courts in India. He never stopped using caste whenever it suited him.
Perhaps he is the only Judge of
the High Court in India who was given a prison sentence of 6 months by the
Supreme Court.
In 2017, he was a Judge of the
Calcutta High Court. He then passed an order sentencing the CJI and 7 other SC
Judges to 5 years imprisonment. Clearly
that was a bizarre and nonsensical sentence because as the Judge of the
Calcutta High Court he had no Jurisdiction to try the Judges of the Supreme
Court and the sentence was a farce.
He claimed that they had
humiliated and harassed him due to his background as a Dalit. Surely that is an
absurd charge which he has used because of the protection granted to his caste
by the constitution. Even if they really did so he is a nobody to sentence them
without providing any evidence. No citizen of India including the CJ has the
power to sentence anyone without proof. This fellow thought too much of
himself.
He claimed that he was
ill-treated and targeted ever since his tenure at the madras High Court and the
Calcutta High Court. His name for elevation as a High Court Judge was
recommended in 2009 by the High Court Collegium comprising of Justice AK
Ganguly, Justice SJ Mukhopadhyaya and Justice PK Mishra. All the 3 were
Brahmins. Has this man forgotten that his name has been recommended by this
collegium to be the Judge? If he is indeed discriminated against, then he would
not have been promoted as a High Court Judge at all in the first place.
After Karnan wrote letters accusing
several Judges of corruption but without any evidence, a 7 Judge bench of the
SC has initiated suo moto contempt proceedings against him, stripped him off
Administrative and Judicial work and ordered a psychiatric evaluation.
In retaliation, by invoking the
SC ST atrocities Act 1989 he passed an order sentencing the CJ and the 7 judges
to 5 years imprisonment, imposed fines and ordered restrictions on them.
Clearly this is a case of shamelessly using the Act for his personal benefit
and by also using an authority which he did not possess.
The SC immediately dismissed his
order as non-existent and sentenced him to 6 months imprisonment for criminal
contempt. He then absconded from his duty till superannuation on June 12, 2017 and
the Police arrested him on June 20th 2017 at Coimbatore and was
imprisoned for 6 months. Even after that Karnan continued to openly denounce a
large number of judges with allegations of corruption and caste based
discrimination, but without any proof of course. He passed away yesterday and
perhaps I should not be saying this, but to me he looks a most evil man who
used the system to throw mud at others but without providing any proof. He
considered that everyone in India are subservient to him and have to obey his
whims and fancies.
No comments:
Post a Comment