Monday, 10 October 2022

FUNDAMENTAL PARTICLES OF THE UNIVERSE

 There was a time when people thought they knew everything about fundamental particles when they came to know about the Electron, Proton and the Neutron.

But as science and research progressed the number of fundamental particles went on expanding. With what is known as of today, there are 31 particles of which 25 are fundamental particles in the Universe.

Let us examine what they are.

Scientists have classified two fundamental types of particles; Matter Particles and Force Particles.

Some of the Matter particles combine to produce the world around us.

In the force particles one, the Photon is responsible for electromagnetic radiation.

Matter particles are known as Fermions, and the Force particles are known as Bosons.

MATTER PARTCILES or FERMIONS: .

Fermions are divided into 1. Leptons &  2. Hadrons

 

The Leptons  are divided into

1. Electrons,

2. Muons,

3. Tau,

4. Electron Neutrino,

5. Muon Neutrino

6. Tau Neutrino

 

The Hadrons are divided into 1. Baryons &  2. Mesons

The Baryons in turn are divided into

      1. Proton

2.       2. Neutron

3.       3.  Lamda

4.       4. Omega

5.       5. Up Quark

6.       6. Down Quark

7.       7. Top Quark

8.       8. Bottom Quark

9.       9. Charm Quark

1       10. Strange Quark

The Mesons are divided into

1.      1.  Pion

2.       2. Kaon

3.       3. B-zero

4.       4. Ela C

FORCE PARTCILES or BOSONS: .

The Bosons are divided into

1.       1. Photon

2.       2. W- Boson

3.       3. W+ Boson

4.       4. Z0 Boson

5.       5. Gluon

So there are currently altogether 25 fundamental particles in the Universe governing Matter & Force. Of them, 20 are Fermions & 5 are Bosons. 

CHOLA DYNASTY

 

The Chola dynasty is one of the longest dynasties in world history and ruled for some 850 years or even more. The Cholas were the only Indian dynasty that attacked kingdoms outside the Indian sub-continent. They had a very strong navy that enabled them to invade countries far away from them by sailing the sea.

The earliest reference to the Cholas comes from the inscriptions of Ashoka. They were not subject to Ashoka but were on friendly terms with him. Apart from the edicts, they were also mentioned in the Sangam period Tamil literature between 6th century BC to 3rd century AD.

Along with Cheras and Pandyas they continued to rule the areas of Tamilnadu & Kerala. Varayur, a part of Tiruchirapalli was their first capital. Kaveripttinam was another old capital. The heartland of the Cholas was the Kaveri river valley.

There is not much information about the Cholas after the Sangam period after 300 AD. After that there was a fight for ascendancy in the area was between the Pallavas and Pandyas.

Around the 7th century, a Chola kingdom flourished in the present day Andhra Pradesh. They are known as the Telugu Cholas. It is possible that a branch of the Cholas has migrated north to AP to escape the influence of the Pallavas and the Pandyas.

As against being a Kingdom earlier, the Chola Empire begins only in the mid-9th century AD with Vijayalaya Chola. He captured Tanjavur between 848 and 851 AD from the Pallavas. Now, Vijayalaya could have risen overnight and therefore the Cholas must have ruled as a smaller feudatory of the Pallavas or Pandyas in the interregnum.

Vijayalaya Chola was the founder of the Chola Empire. Taking opportunity from enmity between the Pallavas and the Pandyas, he seized Tanjavur and it became the capital of the Chola Empire.

Through their leadership[ and vision, the Cholas expanded their empire.

The 2nd king of the Chola dynasty Aditya I defeated both the Pallavas and the Pandyas of Madurai in 885 AD and occupied large parts of Kannada country.

In 925 AD, his son Parantaka I conquered northern Ceylon. He also defeated the Rashtrakuta king Krishna.

Rajaraja Chola and Rajendra Chola were the greatest kings of the Chola dynasty. At its peak the Chola Empire stretched from Srilanka in the South to the Godavari-Krishna river basin in the North, and the entire Chera country and up to the Konkan coast. The eastern coast up to the Ganges was conquered later. Cholas had a great navy and they also conquered Lakshadweep and Maldives with it.  Rajaraja conducted a land survey of his empire in the year 1000 AD.

His son Rajendra Chola I conquered Orissa, marched north and defeated the Pala dynasty of Bengal and reached the Ganges river. He built a new capital Gangaikonda Chaolapuram to commemorate his victories in North India.

He also successfully invaded the Kingdom of Sri Vijaya in Indonesia which resulted in the decline of that kingdom. This perhaps happened because the Cholas were friendly with the Angkor kingdom in Cambodia and the Empire of Sri Vijaya was harassing it.

Rajendra Cholas name was mentioned in the medieval Malay chronicles as Raja Chulan. The Chola armies invaded Malaysia, Indonesia and Southern Thailand. An attack was also launched against the Burmese kingdom of Pegu. These attacks which were primarily for plunder but did not annex those territories. They weakened the empire of Sri VIjaya and finished it off. The trade of Sri Vijaya was taken over by the Tamil Trade Guilds which were very powerful then. It was also said that tehse guilds were one of the reasons why Rajendra Chola attacked the Empire of Sri Vijaya. They wanted more access to trade and have therefore exerted their influence on the king for the attack.

Rajendra Chola completed the conquest of Ceylon and took the Sinhala king Mahinda as prisoner. He conquered the territories of the Rashtrakutas and the Chalukyas. The kingdoms on the East coast up to the river Ganges acknowledged the Chola suzerainty. He sent 3 diplomatic missions to China.

The Western Chalukyas tried to regain their territories but their armies were routed repeatedly by the Cholas. The Chalukyas have been reduced to nothing by the Cholas. Finally their feudatories the Hoysalas, the Yadavas and the Kakatiyas gradually increased their power and finally replaced them in their territories. The Cholas remained stable until 1215 AD but were finally absorbed by the Pandyan Empire and ceased to exist by 1279 AD.  

 

Monday, 5 September 2022

MESOPOTAMIAN CIVILIZATIONS.

 

When we mention Mesopotamia, we mean all the civilizations that have occurred in the area between the Tigris and the Euphrates rivers in Iraq.

Several civilizations flourished there one after another. The first was the SUMERIAN civilization. The first city of this civilization was “URUK” which came up around 3200 BC. It had a population of 50,000. The Sumerians started the earliest form of written language known as cuneiform tablets.

By 3000 BC the Sumerians controlled the entire Mesopotamia. Their cities were ERICH, ERIDU, KISH, LAGASH, URUK and UR. The first king of a united Sumer was one Etana of Kish. They also produced the world’s first literature which was named the “Epic of Gilgamesh”. This started as poems and tales dating back to 2100 BC, but the final version was written down by the Babylonians in 12th century BC. This was later lost till it was unearthed at Mosul in Iraq by archaeologists.

The Sumerian civilization fell to the Semitic AKKADIANS in 2334 BC. The Akkadians were led by SARGON THE GREAT. The Akkadian empire lasted for 180 years between 2334 and 2154 BC.

This was the world’s first multicultural empire with a central government. Sargon conquered all of Sumer and also Syria. Under him trade beyond the borders grew and architecture improved. After that there was civil unrest and the Sumerians took control again only to be defeated by the Semitic AMORITES from the Arabian Desert in the West and the ELAMITES from the East in 1950 BC.  

While the Elamites attacked Southern Mesapotamia and took cities like Ur, the Amorites attacked the North and one of the villages captured by them later grew into a great city called Babylon.

Sometime before 1800 BC the Amorites set up their first king in Babylon. However, the Babylonians could get control of entire Mesapotamia only by time of Hammurabi who ruled between 1790-1750 BC. The Babylonian language developed and the Sumerian fell into decline.

Hammurabi was one of the greatest rulers of ancient times. He gave a code of laws to the people and also enforced them. This is the oldest surviving law in the world. The code was originally inscribed on a huge basalt rock. This is now in the “Louvre” museum at Paris. The text of his code runs like the edicts of king Ashoka some 1400 years late.

I rooted out the enemy above and below,

I made an end of war,

I promised the welfare of the land,

I made the peoples rest in friendly habitation,

I have governed them in peace. I have sheltered them in my strength.

 

There were 280 parts of the code with rules and regulations for Babylonian society which was split into 3 classes;

 1. Amelu--Nobles, warriors & officials

2. Mushkinu—Commoners, merchants, craftsmen and farmers,

3. Wardu—Slaves

 

The laws varied according to classes. See the resemblances to our own Manu.

 “ If a noble has broken  another nobles bone, they shall break his bone.”

“If he (noble) has destroyed the eye of a commoner or has broken the bone of a commoner, he shall pay one mina of silver”

 Theft from a noble had to be repaid 30 times, but theft from a commoner only 10 times. If a house collapsed and killed the owner, the builder was put to death. If the house killed the owners’ son, then the builders’ son has to die.

 Surprisingly Hammurabi was concerned about the treatment of women and that was in 1700 BC which is simply amazing.  He enacted laws allowing women to inherit the husband’s house, land and possessions.  He also introduced legal formalities in business transactions. No one could sell property or transfer it without a written contract. Hammurabi also regulated wages and setting down maximum rates of work in various trades.

 Hammurabi did not invent these laws but he assembled the laws prevalent at that time and also added his own to them. The code was inscribed on a huge pillar so that his people would know what their legal rights were. Hammurabi also extended and improved the canal system of Babylon.

 The knowledge of the Babylonians in mathematics was enhanced by their contact with the Egyptians.

By about 1700 AD, the Babylonians were using multiplication tables, square roots and even some algebra. They understood Geometry and the principles later stated as the theorem of Pythagoras.

We derive the 60 minutes in an hour and 360 degrees in a circle from them. The first library in the world was at Babylon where the books were preserved on papyrus rolls.

Babylonians loved poetry and their favourite epic was the “Epic of Gilgamesh” which was originally Sumerian but was absorbed into the Babylonian literature. The legend survives to this day.

Babylon also had the first standing army in the world, so its borders were fully protected from infiltration by any invader.

When this remarkable king did in 1750 BC, he left no capable successor to takeover and Babylon fell on bad times. First to the HITTITES and later to the KASSITES both Indo European (Aryan) races who lived in the regions of Persia.

SUSHANT SINGH RAJPUT.

 

He was born at Patna to Krishna Kumar Singh, as the youngest of 5 children. The rest 4 were his sisters. One of his sisters Mitu Singh became a state level cricket player later. His family moved to Delhi after his mother’s death in 2002 where he completed his schooling.

He was an avid reader and was fond of Astrophysics and won the National Olympiad in Physics. He wanted to become an Astronaut or an Air force pilot, but his family put him into studying Mechanical Engineering at Delhi College of Engineering. He was also interested in Bollywood being a fan of Shah Rukh Khan.

When he was doing his Engineering he enrolled in Shiamak Davars dance troup and attended classes under theatre director Barry John. In his 4th year of Engineering he dropped out of college and decided to take up a career in Bollywood. He moved to Bombay and took up odd jobs. He then joined Nadira Babbars theatre group and stayed with it for two and half years.

He was cast as a 2nd lead in the TV serial ‘Kish Desh Me Hai Mera Dil” in 2008. Ekta Kapoor was very impressed by him and cast him in another serial “Pavitra Rishta” being telecast in Zee channel against their wishes. He won various Television awards for his role.

In 2011 Sushant Singh was cast in “Kai Po Che” The film has earned a commercial and critical success. For the film, Sushant received a Filmfare nomination for best debutant actor. 

He then starred in Amir Khans PK and later in “Sudh Desi Romance” in 2013 which became hits. Shekhar Kapoor then described him as the most inspiring young actor to emerge out of India. And he was occasionally referred to as the next Shah Rukh Khan. He then starred in “Detective Vyomkesh Bakshi” released in 2015 which was a critical success if not a commercial one.

He was then cast in “ MS Dhoni: The Untold Story” released in 2016 and of course it was a great success becoming the 5th highest grosser that year. He received critical acclaim and was nominated for many prestigious awards including “ Filmfare Awards, International Indian Film Academy Awards and winning a nomination for the Film Festival of Melbourne.

At the time of release of Dhonis biopic Sushant told the media that he was signed for 5 other films “Rabta, Takadum, Chanda Mama Door Ke and 2 other films. In Rabta Sushant and Alia Bhat were cast in the lead roles in 2015 but Alia Bhat dropped out later in the same year. In 2017 he featured in the Forbes India’s top 100 list.  Rabta released with Kriti Sanon as the lead instead of Alia Bhat in 2017 and it flopped.

He started shooting for Karan Johars “Drive” along with Jacqueline Fernandez but the release of the film was postponed twice in 2018 on account of differences between Karan Johar the producer and Mansukhani the Director.

His next film Kedarnath of Abhishek Kapoor and Ekta Kapoor was initially embroiled in controversy as the theme had an inter religious marriage between a Hindu and a Muslim and the BJP wanted it banned.  It was banned in some districts in Uttarakhand and despite the ban became a commercial success.

In 2018 Sushant was inducted into a company named “ Innsaei Venntures” along with 2 other directors already there. They planned to invest Rs 300 crores in the company which worked in the fields of intellectual property and emerging technologies. He was signed in by the NITI Ayog to become a brand ambassador of the Women’s Entrepreneurship Platform and for promotion of the BHIM mobile payment app.  The same year Rajput announced a creative venture by Innsaei of a 12 biopic series where he would play the role of various historical characters between the years 540 BC to 2015 AD.

In 2019 his film “Sonchiriya” was released. It received positive critical reviews and picked up awards but was not a commercial success. Then came “ Chhichhore” released in 2019 and it became a commercial success. Before the release of his film “Sonchiriya” in an interview Rajput revealed that he was in talks for 12 other films including Chandamama Door Ke.

Finally his old film “Drive” of Karan Johar that was pending for release was released on Netflix in Nov 2019 as a cost cutting measure.

In 2019 he featured for a 2nd time in the Forbes annual top 100 celebrity list. In January 2020 Sushant floated an NGO “Front India for World Foundation” with intent for working towards eradication of poverty, hunger and malnutrition.

In 2017 Rajput was signed for a directorial debut of Mukesh Chabra for a Hindi remake of a Hollywood film. It was finally titled “Dil Bechara” and also featured Saif Ali Khan and Rehman as a music composer. The release date was set for May 2020 and it could not be released due to Covid. It was finally aired through Hotstar after his death and had a record number of views.

Sushant’s personal life had its share of controversies. In 2011 Rajput proposed to his co star Anikta Lokhande on the show Jhalak Dikhlaja during a National Broadcast. In 2012 they started living together. The media talked about their marriage. Rajput stated in an interview that marriage and living together are no different and it is hypocritical to say that the former is legal while the latter is a crime. In 2016 Rajput confirmed that a lavish wedding would be held in December but they separated before that. Which means they lived together for 4 years?

He was later rumored to be dating his Rabta Co star Kriti Sanon which was denied by both. When the sets of Padmaavat were vandalized by the Rajput Karnisena, Rajput supported the producers of the film. For his role in “Chandamama Door Ke” he was sent to NASA for training which he wanted to go back and complete his instructor training for the Artemis program of 2024. He also purchased a 16 inch telescope for stargazing. He had a collection of 125 books on his subjects of interest which included Astrophysics, Physics, Cognitive science and Behavioral Economics.

He used to bring books to the sets and used to read them during the breaks. In 2018 there was another rumor that he is dating his “Kedarnath” co actress Sara Ali Khan but the rumors were never confirmed and they broke up.

In 2019 he started dating Rhea Chakravarthy. They met at a party in April 2019 and dated thereafter.  She found a company for artificial intelligence named Vividrage with her brother and Rajput in Sep 2019. However, it just had a nominal paid up capital. They moved together in December 2019 and lived with Rajput till 8th June 2019 when she moved out. On 9th June Rajput's manager Disha Salian committed suicide by jumping out of the 14th floor of a building and Rajput committed suicide on 15th June.

 He conveyed to his father that he would marry in 2021 but his father knew about only Ankita Lokhande and nothing about the others.

On 14th June 2020 Rajput aged 34 was found dead in his Bandra home hanging from a ceiling fan. As per the post mortem death occurred between 11.30 AM and 1.30 PM. Police said it was a case of suicide and he was suffering from clinical depression and bipolar disorder. No foul play was noticed by the police. On 25th July Rajputs father lodged an FIR at the Patna police station naming Rhea Chakravarthy and 5 others of abetment of suicide.

On 31st July the Enforcement Directorate has filed a case to investigate money laundering of Rajputs accounts by Rhea Chakravarthy, her parents and associates.

Sunday, 4 September 2022

THE TAIWAN DISPUTE

 

Taiwan was formerly known as Formosa. Taiwan lies in the Pacific Ocean, about 160 Km from the South eastern part of the mainland China. It is 400 Km long and has a 145 Km width at the broadest point. It comprises of 86 islands.

In the 13th century the Han Chinese fishermen started settling on the Penghu islands which are a part of Taiwan. Very few outsiders visited the main island of Taiwan till the 16th century. Then it was visited by fishermen and traders from Fujian in China, and also both by Chinese and Japanese pirates.

The Dutch East India Company tried to set up an outpost on Penghu islands of Taiwan but was driven away by the Ming forces from China. Finally in 1624 the company managed to set up a stronghold called Fort Zeelandia in Taiwan. When they arrived they found the area to be peopled by about 1500 Chinese. The company encouraged the Chinese from Fujian to settle there and work on Dutch plantations. By the 1660’s 50,000 Chinese were living on the island.

In 1626 the Spanish came in and made Northern Taiwan their base. But by 1642, the Dutch overthrew the Spanish.

After the Ming dynasty fell in 1644 in China, a vassal king was pressurized by the incoming Qing dynasty and shifted his base to Taiwan and in the process expelled the Dutch from Taiwan.

The Dutch now aligned with the Qing dynasty of China. They took a part of Taiwan and made a base but could not make any further progress and withdrew from Taiwan altogether in 1668.

In 1683 the Qing dynasty of China finally annexed Taiwan and ruled till 1895. Japan took Taiwan after a war with China in 1895. A group of high officials loyal to the Chinese Qing dynasty proclaimed the Republic of Formosa in 1895 against the Japanese rule and there was guerrilla resistance to the Japanese in which 14000 Taiwanese were killed. However, the rebellion against the Japanese was not successful.

In October 1944 during the 2nd world war, the Formosa air battle was fought between the US carrier forces and the Japanese forces in Taiwan. During the war, many Taiwanese joined the Japanese forces.

However, after the war was over, most of Taiwan’s Japanese numbering around 300,000 were expelled to Japan. The Chinese forces assisted by teams of US forces landed in Taiwan and captured it. Later Despite handing it over to China, the allies considered Taiwan to be under the Japanese till 1952 the treaty of San Francisco as per which the possession of Taiwan passed on to China.

However, there was a problem for the transfer because in 1949 there was a communist revolution in China and the Nationalists led by Chiang Kai Shek were defeated. Chiang took about 2 million of his followers and migrated to Taiwan adding to the already present 6 million population there. He then formed a Republic of China (ROC) government there.

Now the problem for Japan is whether to hand over Taiwan to the Peoples Republic of China (PRC) or to the Republic of China (ROC) government? China did not attend the signing of the treaty of San Francisco and Japan surrendered the areas to Formosa without actually specifying to whether the surrender was to ROC or PRC.

Taiwan always claimed mainland China while the mainland China in turn claimed Taiwan. But, as you can see, right from 1895 onwards Taiwan had never been a part of China. That is 127 years till now. Yes, it was administered by China for 300 years before 1895, but as long as it is not contiguous with China and the people are not willing to accept China then China should not interfere with Taiwan. Moreover, the forms of government adopted by both is diametrically opposite with one being a democracy and the other Communist.  

NATIONAL HERALD SCAM

 

National Herald is a newspaper published by The Associated Journals Ltd. And is owned by Young India Ltd. a company owned by Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi.

National Herald was first published from Lucknow by Jawaharlal Nehru in 1938. Nehru also started the Associated Journals Ltd. in 1937 with 5000 freedom fighters as its shareholders. Till Nehru was appointed as PM he was the Chairman of the Board of Directors of National Herald. The paper was closed in 2008 due to lack of revenue. When it was shut down it had 1000 shareholders. So, what happened to all those shareholders? The National Herald was re launched by Rahul Gandhi in 2017.

The case on National Herald was filed by Subramaniam Swamy against Sonia Gandhi, Rahul Gandhi, their companies and their associated persons in the year 2012.

As per the compliant Associated Journals took an interest free loan of Rs 90.25 crores from the Congress and the loan was not repaid. A closely held company Young India was incorporated in 2010 with a capital of Rs 50 lacs it acquired virtually all the shareholding of AJL and its properties valued at Rs 5000 crores. The debt of Rs 90 crores due from AJL to Congress was assigned to Young India and that is how Young India got hold of AJL. Obviously this can be nothing but a fix.

I checked the shareholding of both AJL and Young India. AJL had a paid up capital of Rs 91.31 crores. Young India paid up capital Rs 5 lacs (and not even 50 lacs as Swamy claimed).

So a company with a paid up Capital of Rs 5 lacs acquired a company with a paid up capital of Rs 91.31 crores. Wonderful.

Look at the Directors of AJL and Young India…..all Congressmen or chamchas.

Directors of AJL   

 Shyam Pitroda,

Arvind Mayaram- IAS Officer of 1978 batch currently appointed as Chief Economic Adviosr by Rajasthan Government.

Pawan Kumar Bansal- Former Minister in MMS Government

 Mallkarjuna Kharge,

Suman Dubey-Former journalist and founder of the Rajiv Gandhi Foundation. Former Press Adviosr to Rajiv Gandhi.

 Prashanto Chandra Sen. –Prcticing Senior Advocate of the Supreme Court

Directors of Young Indian----

Sonia Gandhi

Rahul Gandhi

Mallikarjuna Kharge

Shyam Pitroda

Pawan Kumar Bansal

Suman Dubey

Sonia and Rahul own 38% each in Young India. The rest is owned by Kharge et al.

 

SARADHA SCAM OF WEST BENGAL

 

The Saradha group was established in the year 2006 under the name of Ramakrishna Paramahamsa’s wife. Sudipto Sen was Chairman and MD of the Saradha group. The land bank he formed in the year 2000 on account of his activity in land development became an attraction for attracting investors to his Ponzi Scheme.

The group promised huge returns on the amounts invested in Chits. They employed agents to sell the scheme in rural areas and 25% to 40% of the deposits were paid as commission to the agents. Initially, they collected money through secured debentures and redeemable preferential bonds. In doing this it already violated the Indian Security Regulations & the Companies Act.

SEBI confronted the Saradha group in 2009. Then the group adapted by opening 200 new companies to create cross holdings, create confusion and confound SEBI. SEBI persisted on in its investigation in 2010. The group then changed the way it raised capital and used collective investment schemes of Tourism packages, forward trading, hotel booking, timeshare credit transfer, real estate, infrastructure finance and motorcycle manufacturing. Investors were simply promised high returns and were totally unaware of the modus operandi of the company.

It also started raising funds through Chit Funds. SEBI warned the West Bengal government about its Chit Fund activities in 2011. This reporting made the Sardha group to change its methods. It bought and sold large number of shares of listed companies and embezzled the amounts  which could not be identified. It also started laundering a large proportion of its funds to Dubai, South Africa and Singapore. By 2012 SEBI could catch that the money is obtained from collective investment rather than for Chit Funds and directed the Saradha group to obtain permission from SEBI for its activities. The group simply ignored it and operated its schemes till its collapse in April 2013.

Earlier, with huge amounts of money at its disposal, it went on to build its image in the public eye by investing in the Bengali film industry and then by recruiting TMC MP Stabdi Roy as brand ambassador and also TMC MP Mithun Chakravarthy. Kunal Ghosh another TMC MP, Kunal Ghosh was made the CEO of its media group. Under him 1500 journalists were recruited and 8 newspapers were printed in 5 languages. Author Aparna Sen was made the editor of Parama, a Bengali weekly brought out by the group.  

CONTROVERSIAL DELHI LIQUOR POLICY

 

After implementation of the new liquor policy on Nov 17, 2021, the Delhi Government shut all government run vends and handed them over to private vendors.

The government said the new policy would eliminate liquor mafia, increase revenue for the government and enhance consumer experience.

When the old Policy was scrapped, the Delhi Government set a goal of about Rs 9500 crore a year on liquor license fees by allowing private companies to open 850 shops in 32 zones.

The Chief Secretary of Delhi released a report on July 8 on the liquor policy alleged financial irregularities. After this report was released and created a storm the AAP government cancelled the new liquor policy.

Now, what are the figures that accrued out of the enw policy and what is the comparison?

A state cabinet note said on Aug 2 that Rs 6720 crores came from VAT & license fee in 2021-22. The policy was implemented on Nov 17 last year but the note does not say what are the revenue accruals between Nov17 2021, and March 31 2022. So, there is no way of knowing how much revenue accrual was there for 2021-22 after the policy was implemented.

In 2020-21 the state revenue was Rs 7039 crores. In the first quarter of the financial year 22-23 i.e. for the 3 months between April 1st and June 30th (under the new policy) the revenue fell short of the budgeted estimates by 38% . And during this time the liquor sale has actually gone up by 59.46%.

As per the revenue accrued for 2020-21 (last FY) the quarterly revenue should have been at least  Rs 1760 crores. But the actual accrual was Rs 1485 crore. This is shortfall of Rs 275 crores in a single quarter compared to last year.

This drop was admitted by the Delhi government itself. The irony is this Rs 1485 crores also includes the refundable liquor deposit of Rs 980 crores by the vendors. So, the actual revenue for the Apr-Jun quarter was just Rs 505 crores ( Rs1485 crores- Rs 980 crores)

Delhi government claims that court relief to several liquor vends in license fees and also prohibition on opening shops in non-conforming areas by civic bodies led to this drop.  

But whatever the government may say, people do not stop taking liquor if it is available and the government cannot offer any explanation as to why the liquor revenues had gone down that drastically when its sale has actually gone up by 60%. The cost of liquor had not been brought down in Delhi after the new policy, and that actually means the benefit the state has lost has actually gone to the vendors. If this is not a scam, then none is. 

 

In its FIR filed on August 17 it accused Sameer Mahendru, the MD of Indospirit group of transferring Rs 1 crore into the bank account of Radha Industries owned by Dinesh Arora. Arora is a partner in 13 hospitality and entertainment companies.

The FIR also says that a person named Arjun Pandey has once collected a cash amount of Rs 2-4 crores from Sameer Mahendru on behalf of Vijay Nair.

Vijay Nair is associated with the AAP’s poll campaign and social media strategies and is the founder of Only Much Louder an event management company.

BJP claims Arjun Pandey is the CEO of the India Ahead News channel which was founded by Bhupendra Choubey. Choubey is married to AAP MLA Atishi’s sister.

Now look at that; Kakinada has a connection with this. The India Ahead News channel belongs to Andhra Prabha whose MD is none other than Mutha Gopalakrishna.

Rs 30 crores:

Puducherry based Pixie Enterprises (P) Ltd. won the license rights for 10 shops in the airport zone for Rs 240 crores. The airport authorities had a running agreement with Buddy Retail Pvt. Ltd owned by Amit Arora and Bhaskar Venisetty and therefore refused NOC to Pixie Enterprises.

The government later returned a deposit of Rs 30 crores to Pixie Enterprises which allegedly violated the excise rules. Sisodia said Buddy was granted the license after it matched Pixie’s offer.

A letter from the Chief Secretary of Delhi Naresh Kumar dated 06th August and a report by the Directorate of intelligence, said the return violated the excise rules.

The Vigilance report said that excise officials on July 8 last year quoted an incorrect subs section from the rules to return the deposit. The relevant sub section mandates that if successful bidders fail to get approvals from the authorities, their deposit would be forfeited.

Rs 144 crores

The Delhi government imposed severe restrictions in December and January on account of Omicron. As the liquors ale dropped the vendors approached the government for license fee waiver. The government waived 24% of the license fee from Dec 28 to January 27. This resulted in a loss of Rs 144.36 crores to the Government.  

The accounts department pointed out that waiver cannot be more than the drop of sale which is 21.60% but the government did not pay heed.

And what was the defence of Excise officials to this? They say as a responsible government Delhi government provided a series of direct and indirect relief to the society of which this is one.

Rs 8000-10000 crore

This is merely a hocus pocus allegation by the BJP. But the Delhi government itself conceded that the revenue loss on account of the new policy for the first quarter of this year (Apr-Jun 22) is 37.51% and that is a huge loss to the state alright. Obviously the rates have been tampered in such a way to benefit the vendors in the new policy.

In January 2022, the government reduced the dry days from 23 last year to just 3 this year. The government also removed a levy of Rs 50 per case on beer.

GADI OF TELENGANA -MINIFORT OF THE DORAS

 

In Telengana, the Deshmukhs survived as local chiefs whose sphere of power often spread to a Paragana which consisted of 20 to 60 villages. They were primarily Revenue Collectors and when Magisterial and Judicial powers were added to their function, they have become Dehmukhs. Gradually their territory became a ‘Watan” or hereditary lease. No ruler at the top dared to tamper with this arrangement. The Deshmukhs presided over meetings known as the Got Sabha which decided and confirmed claims over inheritance, purchase and transfer of lands. The Deshmukhs could not be displaced easily from authority from above.

When the British arrived they made them revenue contractors. Some of the Deshmukhs became “Tahuddars” & “ Sarbasatadars. Now they only had the revenue recovery role for specific periods and were dispensed of the Magisterial and Judicial powers. The British had to fight at many places to bring the Deshmukhs under their rule.

The Aswaraopet Deshmukh for example occupied the “Gadi” a neat and strong structure of 1000 yards and maintained at his own expenses, a retinue of 100 peons (sepoys) besides a few horses. In Telengana payment of taxes in kind is prevalent which gave them a chance of taking the revenue in kind and paying cash to the state. This role enlarged their power and made them merchants and usurer’s restricting the local bania.

Due to usurious rates of interest the peasants started deserting their lands and Salarjung I created pro farmer policies. During the period of Salarjungs reforms, the Dehsmukhs got absorbed as landlords and the Deshmukh Watans were practically abolished and the farmers had Ryotwari tenure. In this process the Deshmukh became big landlords with ownership rights over their land. They were also allowed to lease the government land to bring not only deserted lands under cultivation, but also forest lands for conversion to cultivation. In return for these services, they again got more patta land for cultivation.

Large tracts of land in Telangana were thorn and bush and it required great labour and money to convert those lands into cultivable lands. Ordinary farmers had no means of doing this and the officials naturally preferred landlords who had the capital to do so. Thus the historical and ecological reasons did not allow the small peasant holdings in Telengana. There was abundant labour in Telengana which enabled the landlord class to make them serve and enlarge their holdings.

The group that helped the landlords in Telengana were the “ Patels” &  “Patwaris”. The Patel could belong to any caste and undertook police duties, but Patwari is always a Niyogi Brahmin and undertook revenue duties. They too lived in big bulglows in the fashion of Deshmukhs and were served by many servants. The Patwaris were essentially considered as mischievous and dishonest and known for promoting conspiracies in villages.  

The landlords and the officials were at loggerheads but when it came to subduing the population and exploiting them, they became one.

The 3rd group in the village hierarchy are the “Kapus” “Pedda Rytus” or “Pedda Kapus” (they can be of any caste) who are the village landholders with patta rights and had considerable size of landholdings. They became a separate group and distanced themselves from the lower caste Sudras. These guys lived in big type pucca houses, had enough cattle, stocks of grain and agricultural instruments. They dressed like peasants but were educated, but not educated enough to know the ways of the government laws etc. They also did not know Urdu. But they lived with a lot of prestige in the village. They collaborated with the Dora efforts in enforcing caste based labor exploitation.  

The Doras in the process have taken over the authority of the state and kept the whole countryside in their possession. The word Dora in Telengana does not denote Velamas as we believe. Any upper caste person with land, money, ruthlessness and their proximity to local government officials is a Dora. There were Reddy’s, Velama’s and some Brahmins and Muslims were Doras in Telengana.

There was tremendous exploitation of the lower castes by the Doras. In some cases even wearing a shirt by a farmer was punished.

The most notorious Dora families of Nalgonda and Warangal districts were Rapaka or Visnur, Janna Reddy, Nukala Ramasahayam, Pingali and Lingala. Their authority spread over a Paragana. The Dora families increased from the last quarter of the 19th century through acquisition of lands and through ruthless exploitation.

The later Dora families were Kundur, Nayani, Kondur, Katukuru, Pushkuri, Karhar, Kallur, Tadikamalla, Akkiraju, Boinapalli, Gaddam, Gandra and Bandi. By the time of Telengana People’s struggle for Independence almost every village had a Dora. In almost every village and sometimes in a group of hamlets could be found a palatial Gadi. A huge fort like house with wide compound enclosed by a wall with tall gates where the Dora lived with his family members. It also had his dasis and their children. The Dora is served by a large number of Vetti chakiri workers.

The Doras also assumed magisterial powers and exercised them. Although the Patwari controlled the Police, the Doras supervised him. This was not granted by any government but got by virtue of their money and prestige. The Dora’s also started maintaining records of all the activities in the village.

Those landlords by establishing control over Government property (usurped and not given) controlled village resources, and people’s activity were elevated to Doras. All the Poramboku lands in the village were controlled by the Doras.

The Dora’s had usurped the right of enforcing the law and delivering judgments. In the settlement of disputes, the Dora’s authority was unchallenged. In any other village dispute, the Dora’s order is final. It is surprising to see that all these powers were appropriated by the Dora’s without being granted by the state. The Dora’s language, tone and behaviour was infused with arrogance, authority and abuse in order to impose his decisions on the people. Beating, tying the hands behind, and hanging from a branch of the tree became customary and commonplace. The very thought of Gadi evoked terror in the rural masses. A labourer cannot stand erect in presence of the Dora. He has to bend and talk.

The labourers were not permitted to wear a shirt, talapaga, tilak or chappals. When the Dora goes out from the Gadi, people have to bow their heads and move to the side to give way. Women had to run into their houses.

As you can see, these systems are entirely different from what the Jamindars employed in Andhra area. The Jamindars were granted right to collect revenue by the Government but this they rarely did with any oppression.  Also the people of the Andhra area under the British were not as rigidly feudal as the people of Telengana were then.

This peasant oppression by the Doras in Telengana was the highest in India compared to any other state. On account of this finally on 4th July 1946 when a peasant leader was killed by the men of a Dora in Warangal district, a revolution broke out. Beginning in the districts of Nalgonda and Warangal, the rebellion became a revolution all over Telangana. This was aggravated by the activities of the Nizam and Kasim Rizvi and the Razakars. The peasants then turned to communism and at one point 4000 villages of Telangana had communes. As a result of this, all the Doras had to run away to Hyderabad. Ultimately, the Indian army after taking over Telangana attacked the communes and overpowered them.

Tuesday, 26 July 2022

BHIND IN MP, THE HEART OF CHAMBAL VALLEY-ONE OF MY EXPERIENCES.

 

My posting at SBI Bhind Branch as Manager Personal Banking had been fairly long (a full 4 years from 1991 to 1995) and it has given me varied experiences. That is the longest duration I worked at any single place in the Bank. I am writing down my experiences in various places at random and in the process wrote this small narration. Hope some of you at least would find it interesting as the experience is somewhat different from what we tend to have over here. 

Bhind town is the headquarters of Bhind district and had a population of 110,000 as per 1991 census. However I have seen that currently the population of Bhind is over 2 lacs.

Bhind branch had about 30 staff in all, of which about 12 in my division. While the Personal Banking Division which I headed and the Cash Department were downstairs, the Agriculture Banking Division headed by Hemraj was upstairs.

That was my first assignment as the Manager of the Division. It was a big division and we had 120 savings ledgers in all. 2500 pensioners and 600 school teachers drew their pensions and salaries each month from there. The division always had a big rush all the time. All the transactions were manual at that time and people had to be personally present at the branch to withdraw the money as no ATM’s were there. To top it everything was manual excluding the lists of pensioners which we got done from outside.

Ours is the only commercial bank branch at Bhind apart from State Bank of Indore and probably Central Bank of India and Punjab National Bank.

The very first impression I had of Bhind is that so many people carried guns which are licensed. So many guns everywhere. I found that some people carried guns even while travelling on a bicycle. Bhind and the surrounding areas had many Thakurs, and for them to possess a gun is symbol of prestige. There were so many tractors as well because that was also looked as a symbol of prestige by the people. At that time, I have never seen that many tractors anywhere else in MP or for that matter in any other state which I had visited except for Punjab. Our branch alone has financed over 200 tractors and that was in 1991.

I want to give you an idea of the area. Once, the belt of Bhind, Morena  and Mainpuri was famous for dacoits. Since the British times dacoits abounded the Chambal. Although it was said that feudal mindset and exploitation led to dacoity, there is no proof for this, as most of the dacoit gangs have come from a higher caste backgrounds who were economically well off. One of the famous dacoits of the Chambal area is Gabbar Singh on whom the film Sholay was made. Gabbar Singh had the odious the distinction of cutting away the noses on 113 people. Another famous dacoit Malkhan Singh surrendered at Bhind in 1982. Then Phoolan Devi and Man Singh surrendered at Bhind in 1983.            

Bhind district has 29000 licensed weapons, and the adjoining district of Morena 21000, when the number of licensed guns in the entire Bihar state is only 50000. Both Bhind and Morena are the heart of Chambal Valley and part of the Chambal dacoit belt. The nearby Chambal ravines had many dacoits once. The ravines started immediately after Bhind and Chambal river was just 14 Km from Bhind and if one crosses that one enters into Etawah (Mulayam Singh Yadav’s hometown) from UP which is about 38 km from Bhind.

The ASP of Bhind Sushovan Banerjee (He is currently one of the Additional Director Generals of Police for MP) was my customer.  He told me that Bhind district had big dacoit gangs at the time of Phoolan Devi and earllier, and the police were no match for them at that time because the gangs were equipped with automatic weapons (Phoolan Devi Carried a Mauser gun)  and had many members while the Police carried 303 rifles. He also told me that all the big dacoit gangs have been eliminated now and only small gangs of 4-5 people operate and they were no match to the police.

I asked him as to how he finds his job. His remark was the IPS label appears glamorous but only the insiders knew what their position is. Probably there are lots of internal pressures which the public would not be aware of. He told me that the posting at Bhind was good for his career. I asked him how that is so, and he tells me that he has encountered 17 dacoits and that has gone into his service record. Haha some service record that.

The branch was then headed by Chief Manager Mr T.C.Jain who was a Trainee Officer of 1978 batch. He was lame in one leg and walked with a stoop. The Manager Agricultural Banking Division was Shuvinder Hemraj who was a Probationer of 1981 batch which is one batch senior to me. I did not know Hemraj prior to that  and got introduced to him there. Nirmal Singh who was a 1980 batch probationer was a Deputy Manager to Hemraj. The accountant for the branch was S.K.Gurnani.

Since I was posted at Bhind for a long duration of 4 years, a lot of incidents happened. Maybe I cannot remember all of them now because it is too distant in the past, but there are some which are simply unforgettable and I will narrate them now.

The very first incident that comes to mind is that of a shootout because that is something absolutely out of ordinary for us South Indians. As already narrated earlier, when we initially came to Bhind there was no hotel where a family can go and have lunch or dinner.

Bhind was a district headquarters but it lacked such facilities. Also because of its aggressive culture perhaps people thought such a hotel would not be able to run properly. After about 1 year after our arrival at Bhind, one guy called Amar Singh Bhadoria who owned a Gymnasium at Bhind, and had many sishyas set up such a Restaurant named “Mayura”. His elder brother was also the Sub Registrar of Bhind and he comes from an influential Thakur family.

So me and my wife had an opportunity to go and have lunch and dinner there now and then. We were too happy about it and utilized the services of the hotel often. Whenever we visited the hotel Amar Singh Bhadoria cordially welcomed us and it went on like that for about a year. The hotel is quite near to my place and is approached by a side road branching off from the main road to the left.

One day in the morning I came to know that a shooting incident took place at “Mayura” and a young waiter aged about 19 brought in by Amar Singh from Gwalior was shot dead. I was shocked and immediately visited his hotel in order to enquire about the happening.

Since a murder has taken place there the previous day, I thought that there would be police present there. But the scene that presented itself to me was simply stunning. Till that time I saw such scenes only in the movies. Not a single policeman was present at the site, but I found about 20 men holding guns with their shoulders adorned with flashing cartridge belts. Most of them were tall with beards and looked sinister and were like soldiers ready for war.

It was a sight straight out of a Western movie. Amar Singh is nowhere to be seen. The scene shook me and I did not know who those men were, or why they were there. Since I arrived there I had no choice, so I just went to one of the guys and told him that I wanted to meet Amar Singh. That guy went in, and out came Amar Singh to my relief. I asked him as to what was the matter. Amar Singh blurted out “ Saab ladayi hogaya tha. Par jobhi ho, ye hotel to kisi bhi halat me chalega hi aur band nahi hogi” then he said “ Jo hua acha hua, sala dubara is raste se gujar nahi payega”. Probably he assumed that I knew everything about the incident. I did not want to press him any further in that condition, agreed with him and left the place.

Later that day in the Bank I came to know what has actually happened. This incident requires a background to understand it. Behind it was a notorious goonda named Pappu Sharma. This guy used to collect hafta from the shops as they show in movies. Once he was caught by the police and was produced in the court. While the judge was trying his case, he jumped out of the witness box, beat up the judge and ran away. He was caught thereafter and was jailed, but another judge granted him bail. That guy used to roam around with his chelas in Bhind collecting hafta.

Amar Singh was very strict about not allowing liquor in his hotel because he meant that the hotel should be used by families along with other citizens. That day at about 9.30 PM the hotel was about to be closed when Pappu Sharma arrived with 4 other guys. Since Amar Singh knew (Of course all locals of Bhind knew him) who Pappu Sharma was he let the hotel remain open and got them served.

However, after sometime some difference came up between Pappu Sharma and Amar Singh. What exactly it was no one knows, but it was highly likely that it is regarding consumption of liquor. In the process Pappu Sharma exclaimed “Tumhara hotel kaise chalega dekhloonga”. Now Rajput guys are short tempered and take offence easily, and in the process they act first and think later. Amar Singh took it as a challenge to himself and said “Theek hai dekhlenge”. Pappu Sharma then left the place in a foul mood.

Amar Singh knew that he would come back with more men and arms. He stationed 2 of his men on the terrace of the hotel with guns and stationed another 2 men inside the hotel again with guns.

As expected Pappu Sharma reappeared in about 30 minutes with about a dozen guys with half of them armed. Pappu Sharmas group knew that Amar Singh is also a powerful guy in the area and his gymnasium had many students in Bhind. So Pappu Sharma’s group was trying to negotiate for a truce.

However, as the group is uncoordinated, a guy from the back shouted some abuse and the firing started. About 20 rounds of fire was exchanged. Amar Singh’s men were firing under cover while Pappu Sharma’s men were on the road exposed. After the exchange Pappu Sharma himself got injured as buckshot hit him on the forearm and his skin right up till his forearm joint was ripped open. He and his men finally ran away leaving their chappals and also some scooters. After the shootout was over, Amar Singh’s men found a waiter aged 19 lying dead on the floor of the hotel. That guy was brought in by Amar Singh from Gwalior just a few months back. The waiter became too inquisitive at the time when the gunfight was going on ad opened the door slightly to see what was happening. He was caught in the crossfire and died but no one noticed that till the fight was over.

The men I found next morning were stationed there by Amar Singh just in case, if by any chance Pappu Sharma mounts another attack on the hotel during daytime.

Amar Singh continued to run the hotel. Now, which family would visit a hotel where a murder has taken place? On top of that he had a doorman with a semi automatic rifle slung on his shoulder and the cashier had another semi automatic lest the hotel gets attacked again. The hotel then looked right out of a western movie or perhaps even worse because in western movies there are no doormen holding guns.

Now, I relate another incident that happened earlier to this but is linked to it. Since Bhind had no other means of recreation myself, Hemraj, Nirmal Singh and Dr Jain used to meet at each ones residence every Saturday and had dinner. That Saturday the dinner was supposed to be at Dr Jain’s residence. By the time I reached the Doctors place Hemraj and his wife have already reached there but not Nirmal Singh. I could see that the Doctor and his wife’s face are ashen and they were unable to speak anything. I then asked Hemraj as to what the matter was. He told me that some time before that Pappu Sharma and his chelas arrived at the Doctors place and threatened him of dire consequences if he does not take one nurse back. Pappu Sharma told the Doctor neither you nor your nursing home would exist if you do not take that nurse back and I will throw you and all your equipment on to the road.

The story was, previous to that there was a nurse working for the Doctor whom he removed because she was incompetent. That time the doctor just had a clinic. Later he borrowed some money from the bank and set up a small nursing home. Now that nurse wanted to come back but the Doctor was just not willing. Now that nurse knew Pappu Sharma and so she sought his help and Pappu Sharma’s arrival at the Doctors house was a consequence of that.

I told the Doctor, are Jain sab what is there in that, you just make a complaint to the police. I still remember his reply very clearly. He said “Are sab woh to hum ko road par marega”. He felt he had no choice and with great reluctance he finally took the nurse back.

Now when this shootout occurred and Pappu Sharma got hurt and ran away Dr Jain was the most happiest of all in Bhind. Since Pappu Sharma lost face after the incident and cannot possibly threaten him again, so he removed that Nurse from the job after the incident.   

But it is amazing to see in that town that none can remain safe and anyone can be threatened. Luckily, we lived in a place called Bhuta Kothi which had a huge compound around which a number of houses were located all owned by the Bhutas. They were tenanted by a number of people apart from the Bhutas who stayed there. We tenanted the ground floor of the main Kothi which had about 2 large bedrooms and 2 other rooms plus the drawing room. It is large in area but had no ventilation at all. Although there were windows at the front the windows at the back opened on to a narrow dingy alley which had drainage sewers. So the back windows although present could be opened at all and therefore the house has no chance for cross ventilation. The open area in front of the house was however, excellent. It was cemented and had a badminton court right in front of our house. I played badminton for many a day with the 2 young Bhutas and others.

There is one thing I liked about the people of Bhind. They are as straight as an arrow. If they did not like you they would tell you on your face. Scheming rarely happens among them. Of course like everywhere there would always be some exceptions there too.

The bank has given me a number of different type of experiences that added to the thrill of life and this incident is just but one of them.  

 

 

 

Sunday, 17 July 2022

ISRO SCIENTIST NAMBI NARAYANAN SAGA.

 Sometimes, it is said that truth is stranger than fiction. In the cases and harassment meted out to the ISRO scientist Nambi Narayanan certainly strange things have happened. One does not understand why this case was initiated on him in the first place. 

No doubt precedents indicate that he is not completely clean, nevertheless, he was no spy. The subsequent Chairman of ISRO has clearly stated that the documents allegedly passed on to the Maldives spies are not classified, that is they are not much of use. It is surprising as to who initiated this persecution and what the reason behind this was. Who gained by persecuting a top scientist this was is a mystery.

Nambi Naryanan was born at Nagercoil in Tamilnadu in 1941. He studied Mechanical Engineering at an Engineering College in in Madurai. He joined ISRO at TERLS as a technical assistant in the year 1966. He then earned a NASA fellowship and was taken into the Princeton University New Jersey in 1969. He did his master program there in Chemical Rocket Propulsion. Till then India was using solid propellants for rockets and liquid propulsion was unknown.

In 1974, a French company has agreed to transfer the Viking engine technology to India. The transfer was completed by 3 teams. Naryanan led the team of 40 engineers who worked on technology acquisition form the French. The first engine under this program named Vikas was tested by ISRO in 1985 successfully.

ISRO’s internal reports highlighted Narayanan’s excellent organizational and managerial skills. But the reports also noted that he tended to take the credit of his teams work to himself and also instances of him running a personal business. The vigilance cell of ISRO has investigated an allegation of tender manipulation by Narayanan in 1982, but this enquiry was dropped later. In 1994, he submitted his resignation and he was arrested a month later by the Kerala Police.

The arrest was made by Kerala police and IB officials on the basis of a Videographed statement by a colleague that he and Narayanan together had received money for transferring the drawings and documents of rocket drawings to two women from Maldives who were suspected to be spies.

In Dec 1994, the case was transferred to the CBI which was criticized by the media and the opposition in Kerala as some of the people named in the investigation were close to PV Narasimha Rao, the then PM and K.Karunakaran the then CM of Kerala.

Narayanan spent 50 days in jail and claims that the IB officials who investigated wanted him to implicate the Director of the Liquid Propulsion System Centre and when he refused he was tortured until he fell down and was hospitalised. Narayanan has written that the then Director of CBI Sri K.Vijayarama Rao met him in jail after he was jailed for 4 days and claimed that the Director has apologised to him that the case should not have gotten that far. In April 1996, before the General election the CBI submitted the closure report on the case saying there was no spying and the testimonies were obtained by torture.

The closure report was challenged in the Kerala High Court by a police officer S.Vijayan. The issue became political and the Kerala government withdrew the permission given to CBI earlier and asked the Kerala police to take up the case again.

In April 1998, the Supreme Court intervened and asked the Kerala Government to pay each of the accused Rs 1 lac. In 1999 the NHRC asked the Kerala Government to pay Rs 1 crore.

Naryanan retired in 2001.

In 2018, the Supreme Court appointed a panel to probe the alleged torture of Narayanan and awarded Rs 50 lacs for the mental cruelty he suffered all those years.

In 2019 Narayana was granted the Padma Bhushan by the government.

In 2021 the Kerala government settled the case filed against it by paying him Rs 1.30 crores.

In Apr 2021 the SC ordered a CBI probe into the involvement of Police Officers in the controversy. Several of the Police officers filed petitions in different courts of Kerala showing several documents transferring lands between 2004 and 2008 by Narayanan to various CBI officers involved in the investigation.

However, these cases do not make any sense as the closure report on the case was submitted by the CBI in 1996 itself. No reason why he should transfer lands to placate the CBI officials in 2004, 8 years after the closure of the investigation and a clean chit was given to him.